Smart Reviews logo

How to Identify Fake Online Reviews and Protect Your Business Reputation

Online reviews have become a cornerstone of how customers decide where to shop, eat, or even book a service. But here’s the thing: not all reviews are genuine.

Some are fake—designed to mislead potential customers—and they can do serious damage to your business reputation.

Let’s dive into how you can spot fake reviews and protect your business from their harmful effects.

Recognising Fake Online Reviews

Fake reviews aren’t always easy to spot, but there are telltale signs to look for. Here’s how you can identify them:

5 signs of fake online reviews: vague praise, generic language, review spikes, shady profiles, and extreme sentiments - Smart Reviews
  • Too Good to Be True: If a review is overly glowing with phrases like “This is the BEST thing ever!” but lacks specific details, it’s worth questioning.
  • Generic Language: Repeated phrases or vague comments like “Amazing service” without explaining why to raise red flags.
  • Suspicious Timing: Multiple reviews posted within a short time frame could indicate fake activity.
  • Shady Profiles: Check the reviewer’s profile. If they’ve left only one review or their name seems fake, that’s a sign.
  • Extremes: Reviews that are either outrageously positive or intensely negative might not be genuine.

Why Fake Reviews Matter

Let’s face it: fake reviews can hurt your business in more ways than one.

  • Eroded Trust: Customers rely on reviews to make decisions. If they sense fakeness, they’ll lose trust—not just in the reviews but in your business.
  • Legal Risks: In some places, posting or encouraging fake reviews can lead to fines or other penalties. For example, the FTC has new rules targeting deceptive reviews.
  • Hurt Sales: Customers who can’t trust your reviews are less likely to buy from you. It’s as simple as that.
Infographic showing how fake reviews erode trust, create legal risks under FTC laws, and hurt sales by damaging business credibility by Smart Reviews

How to Protect Your Business Reputation

The good news? You can take steps to safeguard your business from fake reviews and build a solid reputation. Here’s how:

Steps to protect business reputation: encourage real reviews, monitor online presence, detect fake reviews, and report them - Smart Reviews

1. Encourage Genuine Customer Reviews

  • Ask for reviews after a purchase or service. A simple follow-up email can work wonders.
  • Make it easy for customers to leave feedback by providing direct links to your review platforms.
  • Avoid offering incentives that might influence the review’s content—honesty is key.
Facebook post example encouraging genuine reviews with direct link after a positive experience to boost customer engagement by Smart Reviews

2. Monitor Your Online Presence

  • Regularly check your reviews on platforms like Google, Yelp, and Facebook.
  • Look for patterns or trends that could indicate fake reviews, like sudden spikes in activity.
  • Respond to reviews—both positive and negative—in a professional, thoughtful way.
Google review example showing positive customer feedback and professional owner response to build trust and boost credibility by Smart Reviews

3. Use Tools to Detect Fake Reviews

  • Platforms like Fakespot and ReviewMeta can analyse reviews and flag suspicious ones.
  • Cross-check reviews across platforms to ensure consistency.

4. Report and Remove Fake Reviews

  • Familiarise yourself with the reporting processes for each review platform.
  • Gather evidence of the fake review, such as screenshots or suspicious activity patterns, before submitting a report.

The Role of Ethics and Compliance

Staying on the right side of the law is crucial. The FTC’s recent crackdown on fake reviews underscores the importance of maintaining ethical practices. Here’s what you can do:

  • Train Your Team: Educate employees about the impact of fake reviews and the importance of authentic customer feedback.
  • Avoid Gray Areas: Never pay for reviews or ask others to post misleading feedback.

By fostering an honest review environment, you’re not just following the rules—you’re building trust with your customers.

Conclusion

Spotting fake online reviews and safeguarding your business reputation doesn’t have to be overwhelming.

By staying alert, encouraging genuine feedback, and taking action against fake reviews, you can build trust and protect your brand.

If you’re looking for an easier way to manage reviews and keep your reputation strong, we’re here to help make the process simple and stress-free.

More articles

The (social) proof is in the pudding.

Have you heard the term ‘social proof’ but are unsure what it’s all about? We’ve got you covered! Social proof is the idea that consumers will adapt their behaviour based on what other people are doing. Nothing new there really? When we see a line of excited customers waiting to eat at a popular restaurant or a […]

Tips and tricks: responding to negative reviews

Top tips Customer reviews can be both a blessing and a curse. Great reviews provide social proof  and put potential customers at ease. On the flip side, not every review can be five stars, and negative customer reviews are almost impossible to avoid. Rather than take your frustration out on your keyboard, use unfavourable reviews as an […]

How to nail asking your customers for reviews

It can be daunting to ask your customers to leave a review, but the benefits far outweigh an awkward moment. Asking for reviews from customers is one of the most powerful customer acquisition and retention strategies you can have up your sleeve. That’s because online reviews can do wonders for your company. They help build […]

A positive spin on negative reviews

It can be daunting to receive a negative review but trust us, it’s not the end of the world! Maybe your team is just having an off day, or a reviewer is proving particularly hard to please? One negative review is unlikely to completely ruin your chances in local search though, so don’t worry too […]

Ready to Boost Your Business with More 5-Star Reviews?

Our review specialists are here to answer your questions, show you how it works, and help you get started – no pressure, just expert advice.
Smart Reviews
Turning Reviews into Results
Credit card

Copyright © 2025. Smart Reviews. All Rights Reserved. Website by Wolf IQ